Categories
Soccer Thorns

Takeaways: Reign 2, Thorns 1

The Thorns fell 1–2 to their rivals from the north on Sunday. It was an exciting game that may be remembered as the moment the Reign completed their transformation into the superteam they’ve looked like on paper since the arrivals of Dzsenifer MaroszĂĄn, Rose Lavelle, and Eugenie Le Sommer.

Back under our old friend Laura Harvey and playing for the first time ever at the Seahawks’s Lumen Field, the Reign employed a clever game plan that both maximized their strengths and capitalized on the weaknesses in Portland’s setup.

Let’s take a look at the Reign’s first goal, which exemplifies both sides of that equation. In the screenshot below, Portland has just won possession off a Reign goal kick, and MaroszĂĄn is chasing Lindsey Horan, limiting her passing options:

Horan’s options on the left side of the field are cut off; most players would also see the passing lane to Rocky RodrĂ­guez, in the center circle, as being blocked by Rose Lavelle, leaving Christen Westphal on the right as the only option. She’s wide open, too! But whether it’s because Horan isn’t at 100% mentally—she hasn’t looked like she’s quite clicked back into place with the team in the last couple games—or because she’s Lindsey Horan and has completed this pass plenty of times, she opts for RodrĂ­guez. Lavelle scoops up the pass, MaroszĂĄn and Jess Fishlock close in, and Fishlock finds Megan Rapinoe sprinting up the Reign’s left wing:

Clearly, the Thorns are in big trouble now. Westphal and Natalia Kuikka were both pushing forward, leaving tons of space behind them. At this moment, Kuikka is dropping back but has to keep her eye on Le Sommer on the right, while Westphal is miles behind Pinoe, so Emily Menges and Becky Sauerbrunn are left in the lurch. Menges is left guarding Pinoe one on one, and that’s the ballgame.

Portland’s defense found themselves resorting to heroics a number of times in the game, as the Reign took advantage of that wide space. They also cleverly deployed MaroszĂĄn in a false No. 9 role, using her to press the Thorns’ deeper-lying players on defense and then combine with the midfield once her team won the ball. She was effective both with her pressing, as we saw above, and as a creator, notching two chances created on the stat sheet.

Defensively, Tacoma aimed to make the center of the field as claustrophobic as possible for Portland’s dangerous midfield. They used a low line of engagement, generally not pressing above the halfway line, but pestered the Thorns midfield aggressively in their own half. Here it also has to be said that the current Reign midfield of Fishlock, Lavelle, and Quinn—plus MaroszĂĄn, in practice—rivals the Thorns’ for the best in the league. Fishlock, obviously, eats nails for breakfast, Quinn is a gold medal-winning No. 6, and Lavelle is demonstrating she can be a destroyer in addition to an offensive wizard. In short: a formidable trio!

OL also tended to stay compact horizontally, the better to crowd the central midfield. In doing that, they often ignored the Thorns’ outside backs as they pushed forward in the attack. That left Kuikka and Westphal (and anyone else who found themselves wide of the goal area) open to send in crosses, but with the Reign defense packed in tight as Portland tended to be slow to find those options, only one cross out of 18 total found its mark.

This is where things get a little more nuanced. No doubt this was one of Portland’s poorer performances this year, but I also think it was a closer match than a 2–1 scoreline would imply. The defensive strategy I just outlined, like all defensive strategies, had some vulnerabilities. In particular, pressing always opens up space somewhere on the field, and in Tacoma’s case, that space was between their midfield and back line, which is quite a dangerous area of the field to leave space in!

Below, Angela Salem has just won the ball off of Kristen McNabb (I think) and tapped it to the white area that I think is RodrĂ­guez, who is about to find Crystal Dunn in a big comfortable pocket ahead of the Reign defense:

After this, Fishlock and Quinn kept following the ball as the Thorns passed it around, Sophia Smith and Christine Sinclair stretched the OL back line, and Smith ended up with a clear shot at the goal—which she sent straight to Sarah Bouhaddi.

Smith had a handful of similar chances where the Reign midfield’s aggressive orientation toward the ball came back to bite them, ending the game with a team-leading six shots. In other words, the space was there, the Thorns were just too slow and inconsistent in recognizing and capitalizing on it.

That particular chance was a microcosm of Portland’s issues as a whole. A number of players, including RodrĂ­guez and Menges, looked gassed from the starting whistle. This team has had an exhausting schedule in August, playing five games in 16 days. Smith in particular, though, seemed to exemplify what Mark Parsons identified postgame as the real fallout of that schedule.

“Physically I thought, some of the players today, they still looked like they could go,” he said. “But mentally, definitely. Mentally and emotionally, there was a little more in the tank for them, a little less in the tank for us.”

We’ve seen Smith struggle with finishing this season, but from the press box at least, this looked like a slightly different issue. Where in the past, she’s sometimes seemed to be overthinking where to place the ball once she gets in on goal, on Sunday she tended to find those chances and just… kick.

This isn’t to single Smith out—the team was a beat slow across the board, and understandably so. The full week of rest and training ahead is sorely needed, and hopefully the Thorns emerge looking more like themselves.

Categories
Soccer Thorns

Takeaways: Thorns 2, Gotham 1

In what Mark Parsons called the “toughest game of [their] intense five-game streak,” the Thorns came away with all three points against Gotham FC last night. Last night’s game was the fourth meeting of the Thorns and Gotham this year, and marked their second win (the other two were ties).  

Fresh off their ICC win, the Thorns marketed the game as the  homecoming of their Olympians. It was bittersweet to not see AD Franch welcomed back to Providence Park alongside Crystal Dunn, Lindsey Horan, Becky Sauerbrunn, and Christine Sinclair, but that’s business. Parsons wasted no time in slotting the Olympians back into the starting XI, even if that meant deploying them in different positions from their usual. Sinc played the attacking No. 9 instead of her normal distributing role as the No. 10, where Dunn played instead.

To the eye, the Thorns dominated the first half, attacking relentlessly. The numbers told a somewhat different story. While the Thorns did outshoot Gotham 15–1 with seven shots on target, they were only able to score once in the run of play. Postgame, Parsons said he was disappointed that they hadn’t put more of their many opportunities. The lack of goals resulted from misplaced or overshot passes in the final third, where players took one too many touches or played the ball behind a player who was open on goal.

And despite their overall dominance, there were moments where the team looked a little disjointed. Their passing accuracy was only 75%, and they completed 200 passes, 100 less than Gotham did. With more time back, I expect these numbers to rise, but it will be difficult to find the cohesion the Thorns experienced during the Olympic window with victory tours and national team camps expected to take players out. 

Horan, in her first 90-minute appearance for the Thorns since the July 11th game against Gotham, put in a solid shift. She did have a few noticeable mistakes, like early in the first half, when she received the ball unmarked at the top of the 18 and passed it behind Sophia Smith instead of opting to shoot, sending the ball out of play. However, Horan ended the match with the most touches (68), and an above-average passing accuracy of 80%. That she did so well statistically despite struggling to find teammates at certain moments points to how much more dominant this midfield can be when all the Olympians are fully reintegrated.

While individual players may have been off their rhythms at times, the team as a whole knew their job and were successful in keeping a high press. Parsons spoke about how during the Olympic window the Thorns kept their integrity and didn’t change how they played just because half their starters were gone. Gotham started the match in a 3-5-2, attempting to clog the midfield lanes, but the Thorns’ high press was able to overwhelm their formation.

As you can see on the passing map below, Smith, Dunn, and Sinc all pressed high, and were able to find themselves in 1v1 situations with the Gotham defenders.

Credit: Antonio Maza

Rocky RodrĂ­guez and Angela Salem were able to find them with balls over the top, bypassing the overcrowded midfield, which is where many of the Thorns’ shots came from.

The passing map also shows how crucial Salem was as the No. 6. In 65 minutes, she had two key passes and was 100% on accurate long balls, making 28 completed passes. Her distribution helped to connect the back line to the forwards and work the ball around Gotham, exploiting the available space. Salem is a true No. 6, the deepest midfielder, and was replaced by Moultrie, who is still finding her footing and which position she’s most comfortable in. Without a dedicated holding midfielder, the midfield lost its shape, causing most of the play to go through Horan on the left side. 

This shift forced Yazmeen Ryan to drop back, not able to press nearly as high as Sophia had. These subtle changes resulted in a significant decrease in shots taken, with only five in the second half, and led to “poor buildup, pressing, and fatigue” as Parsons said postgame. The Thorns’ 40.8% possession shows that although they’re dangerous, last night didn’t quite represent their full potential, and they continue to lose focus as games reach the 70th minute.  

Sophia Smith deserves a shoutout, too. In the half she played, she was  one of the most dangerous players on the pitch. Parsons said that her not making the Olympic roster, while heartbreaking, was ultimately one of the best things for her as a Thorn, as it provided the consistency she needs to grow. With 100% passing accuracy and three shots on target, she was lethal up top, slicing apart Gotham’s back line and beating players on the dribble, including Erika Skroski, whose ankles she destroyed to get her goal.

Postgame, Smith said she has been working on her off-ball runs, and that work is showing results. As she gets more time to grow (she is only 21, as the commentators never fail to remind us), she will develop into one of the most lethal threats in the league. 

The Thorns go again against the Reign on Saturday, and while there isn’t much time to prepare, hopefully the rhythm and connection between the Olympic players and the team will grow, leading to a game that is equally dominant to the eye and on paper. 

Categories
ICC Soccer Thorns

Game Notes: ICC Day 1

In the opening games of the WICC at Providence Park yesterday, Lyon played beat Barcelona 3–2 in an exciting, high-quality match. Later in the evening, the Portland Thorns played the Houston Dash to a 2-2 tie. The match went to penalties, and the Thorns came out on top, beating Houston 3–1 in the shootout.

But I come to you bringing observations of the 90+ minutes of each game, whether you were cheering for Lyonnais, Barcelona, the Thorns, or the Dash.

FC Barcelona vs Olympique Lyonnais

1. Olympique Lyonnais made the most of their back line while countering. With Barça disorganized defensively after attacking, and some of their players spread out to follow their marks, OL opened up to find space immediately, and their back line sent passes up wide or through the middle. This tactic was used in one of Lyon’s attempts on goal late in the first half, which nearly succeeded. Barça’s defense was often unprepared and didn’t anticipate the sudden switch of speed.

2. Barça used their midfield and attacking third to send crosses through Lyon’s defensive line whenever they were caught flat, which happened often during the first half. Lyon was slow to counter at times, allowing Barça to move in for crosses and runs. Because Lyon’s defensive line was often so flat, they were caught having to rush back on defense to adjust for an incoming shot or pass.

3. The two teams’ ball movement differed visibly. Lyon used fluid movement switching from one side to the other and using passes and runs up the sidelines, while Barça attacked more centrally, sending passes straight through the middle, as well as using many more crosses. That difference was pivotal to the result of the game. Lyon’s passes and runs from wide areas helped spread out Barça’s defense and created gaps to allow Lyon players through their lines. On the other end, Barça’s crosses helped them move the ball efficiently when Lyon’s own defense was slow to recover and drop back.

Photo by Matthew Wolfe

Portland Thorns vs Houston Dash

1. Early on, Portland’s starters struggled with their movement around the field, but gradually settled in as the game continued. The beginning of the match was a little messy, and it took me longer than usual to analyze the teams’ formations and movement, and to gain an understanding of how the two teams were approaching their opponent. As the game progressed, however, the Thorns’ movement improved. Some players started to switch sides to get into more comfortable positions and to confuse any defenders marking them. Forwards Sophia Smith and Taylor Porter, for example, often switched sides. After some of the chaos settled, the Thorns worked their way into the game.

2. The Houston Dash used the width of the field to pressure the Thorns centrally. The Thorns’ 4-1-2-1-2 formation meant they had a lot of players in the central midfield and were able to push several players forward when needed. With the center crowded with Thorns players, Houston had to find an alternative to breaking Portland’s defensive lines. They used the wings on offense, but used their own defensive line to pressure the center of the field and prevent Thorns attackers from getting chances centrally and in Houston’s box.

3. Subs from the Thorns at the beginning of the second half changed things up. With the Dash leading 2–0, a change was needed to at least catch up to the Dash. When Emily Menges, Simone Charley, and Hannah Betfort joined the fray, Charley’s speed meant counter attacks were in order. Bringing the ball forward for attacks more often led to more and more scoring opportunities, including corners—one of which gave the Thorns their first goal.

Categories
ICC Soccer Thorns

My Favorite Things

A lot of good things that I liked happened last night. Here is a list of the best things that happened, in my opinion:

1. Seven total hype reels throughout the evening

2. Barcelona playing in a super-organized possession-based style, which I would bet not a huge amount of money, but some money, that no team has ever done in Providence Park before

3. Wendie Renard (tall)

4. Mariona goals (two)

5. When Amandine Henry scored in the North End

Photo by Matthew Wolfe

6. Melvine Malard goal

7. The ideal combo of sophistication and technical prowess, on the one hand, and yakety sax defensive errors on the other; maybe the best soccer game I’ve ever seen in person

8. Captain Hubly

9. When the Thorns rotated as much of the team as possible because the same 15ish players have been doing everything for like a month and a half, they’ve been on the road two weeks in a row, and the team has four games in the space of 12 days, so a bunch of players got their first starts and minutes

10. When Natalia Kuikka scored with her head after telling her roommate Angela Salem she was going to score with her head

11. When Olivia Moultrie did a direct free kick and it went in the goal, it was still cool even though the Houston keeper should have been able to save it

12. When Rachel Daly got mad

13. When it went to penalties

14. The sky

15. Shelby Hogan’s first penalty save

16. Shelby Hogan’s second penalty save

17. You can guess what this one is

18. When Simone Charley scored the winning penalty

19. That lineup, doing That

Categories
ICC Soccer Thorns

WICC Preview: FC Barcelona and Olympique Lyonnais

To view this content, you must be a member of the Rose City Review Patreon
Already a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to access this content.
Categories
Soccer Thorns

Takeaways: Thorns 1, Pride 1

The Thorns extended their unbeaten streak with a hard-fought 1–1 tie against the Orlando Pride yesterday evening, thanks to Simone Charley’s fourth headed goal of the season. The Thorns beat the Pride 2–1 just a few weeks ago, but that was before then-coach Marc Skinner abruptly left for Manchester United. The Pride they played tonight, under interim head coach Becky Burleigh, was more physical and harder to break down, but the Thorns were able to dig deep and find a point on the road. 

At the outset, the Thorns appeared tight and disjointed. Despite only two changes to the starting eleven from the previous week—with Natalia Kuikka getting the start over Christen Westphal and Marissa Everett stepping in for an injured Celeste Boureille—the team struggled to find a rhythm in the early minutes. That was a departure from previous games, where they’ve started on the front foot: the Thorns have scored 11 times in the first 15 minutes this season, a league record.

Last night was a different story: defensively, the Thorns trailed in the first half, winning 43% of their duels. And it was the Pride who found the back of the net early with a header from Jodie Taylor in the 13th minute. The Pride’s initial run of momentum came off of a 4-v-1 battle against Sophia Smith at the top of the 18, where Smith was offered no support or options to get the momentum on Portland’s side.

After the break, though, the Thorns turned things around. In the postgame presser, Charley and Meghan Klingenberg both framed that change as a shift to “Thorns Soccer,” which refers to the core principles that the team follows. Basically, the players hold each other accountable, focus on process over results, and play the same way regardless of who’s on the field. This consistency allows for them build momentum through a game, to where they can score with ease and class.

And that’s what happened: Charley, who is absolutely on fire, recorded her fifth goal of the season off a free kick by Klingenberg that looked straight off of the training ground. Although the goal didn’t come until the 78 minute, the Thorns had been building for a goal throughout the second half. They recorded three shots on target (up from just one in the first half) and only allowed the Pride four shots total, which is much more typical of the Thorns’ dominant, offense-focused style. 

After the game, the players talked about their first-half struggle in finding a rhythm and acting on what the other team was presenting them with. “Somebody is always going to be open, and we need to find that opportunity,” said Kling after the match. She added that once the Thorns are able to find open spaces in game and make adjustments on the fly, they’ll be “scary good.”

Watching that first-to-second-half shift, it’s clear that the Thorns are more than capable of making necessary tactical adjustments and executing plans, and it’s more of a matter of finding the confidence to adjust on the fly, rather than being too shaken to act without having to wait for a break to discuss what to do. 

The Thorns Soccer that Charley and Kling discussed in the post-game conference was also present on an individual level. Parsons cited that nine players were out for this match, but that those absences showed the depth of the team culture, as players went a full 90 and didn’t relent.

With Portland’s five international players still out, many players have gotten more minutes than they did in the first half of the season, but the tactics that they employ don’t change. Angela Salem, who got deservedly high praise from Parsons postgame, had the second-most touches (77) and the most chances created (5), as well as boasting a 78% passing accuracy. She’s a pivotal player in the midfield, acting as the glue to help facilitate movement forward and maintain possession. Against Orlando, Salem was one of the most successful in exploiting the space that the Pride left open and has made an exceptionally strong case to keep her starting spot on the team, as her visions and consistency are emblematic of the Thorns culture that the team has been cultivating all season. 

Another player it’s impossible not to talk about is Olivia Moultrie, who recorded her second professional start against the Pride and played 82 minutes, nearly double what she played last week. And although she recorded the second fewest touches with 39, her work ethic on the field to recover, pressure, and infiltrate the open space opens up the field for her teammates. Especially in the second half, Moultrie played end to end, making several tackles back in her own 18-yard box, showing that she has the mental fortitude to play with the Thorns. 

As the Thorns head into a busy few weeks, with five games in sixteen days thanks to the Women’s International Champions Cup, it’s crucial that they maintain the momentum they have built during the Olympic period. For this team to succeed, every player has to deeply believe in the “Thorns Soccer” culture that allowed them to get back a point on the road against Orlando.

Categories
Soccer Thorns

Takeaways: Thorns 1, Washington Spirit 0

The Thorns put together a convincing 1–0 win against Washington yesterday to close out the Olympic period seven points clear at the top of the table. Portland earned 16 of a possible 18 points since Christine Sinclair and the USWNT cohort left for Tokyo, only dropping one result in a draw against Gotham.

The game-winner, a sweet header that Simone Charley bounced in off the bottom of the crossbar, was assisted by a gorgeous cross from Olivia Moultrie, who is famously only 15 years old. Moultrie only played 45 minutes—Mark Parsons said after the game that the team is ramping up her minutes gradually—but it was her most impressive outing yet. In contrast to previous games, where many of her minutes have been in garbage time, here she helped set the tone playing a key position in what would turn out to be a calm, competent win.

The Thorns had a numerical advantage in the midfield, with four players there to the Spirit’s three, which Washington tried to neutralize a few ways. First, they were selective about which of the four they left unmarked. Most often this was Angela Salem, the deepest-lying midfielder (though occasionally RodrĂ­guez and Salem would be swapped). Instead of marking her tightly, center forward Ashley Sanchez used careful positioning to cut Salem off as a passing option from the Thorns defense.

When Salem did get the ball, oftentimes Washington would actively drop away from her, preferring to get into a defensive shape rather than trying to win the ball or even force a particular pass. As a result, Salem had the most touches—about .75 per minute—she’s had in any of the last four games, as well as the most attempted passes and the second-highest passing accuracy, at 85.4%.

Leaving Salem largely alone meant players were always available to tightly guard Rocky RodrĂ­guez, Celeste Boureille, and Moultrie, and accordingly, the Thorns found little joy playing through the middle. The Spirit were also selective in marking Meghan Klingenberg and Christen Westphal: they were allowed to send an aimless long ball up the flank, or pass back to the center backs, but were consistently blocked from more targeted forward passes. When they tried to link up with a midfielder, wingers Trinity Rodman or Ashley Hatch would close them down aggressively.

Finally, Washington defended pretty compactly, both horizontally and vertically. That often had the effect of encouraging hopeful long balls, and it also sometimes stretched the Thorns’ back line, as the Spirit would keep dropping as the center backs advanced, and Kling and Westphal pushed higher and higher into the space they were given:

A screenshot showing Washington in their defensive shape, with Kelli Hubly, who is carrying the ball, being left open.

Portland’s defense isn’t egregiously out of shape here, but you can see both Kling and Westphal advancing up the wings, with Kelli Hubly being given few passing options. Five minutes after this, the Spirit came within inches of scoring—stopped only by Westphal’s heroic save off the line—after Menges took a hard touch and gave up the ball with the two outside backs in an even more attacking posture.

So, how did the Thorns manage to score? Moultrie’s impressive crossing ability aside, I would like to call attention to how she positioned herself on the play leading up to it. In the shot below, the problem Washington is about to have is quite clear: with left back Anna Heilferty tracking Simone Charley, Moultrie has a big ol’ space in front of her. Here Boureille has just passed to Emily Menges, who will find Moultrie as she runs into that space.

A screenshot showing Olivia Moultrie unmarked on the right wing, with a large space in front of her, as Celeste Boureille is passing the ball from the midfield back to Emily Mentes.

This was well read by the teen, who found a way to leverage the Spirit’s defensive strategy against them. While Moultrie was generally closely watched by Andi Sullivan while in that central pocket in front of the Spirit’s back line, here she’s figured out that if she drifts wide, the Washington midfield loses track of her, with Tori Huster, Dorian Bailey, and Sullivan worrying about RodrĂ­guez, Boureille, and Salem, respectively.

Just after this screenshot, Hatch could tell what was about to happen—she pointed back toward Moultrie—but she seems to have been torn between dropping back to pick up Moultrie and continuing to watch Westphal, as she was asked to do throughout the game.

Charley also played a key role in setting this up, as she dragged Heilferty inside to open up that space on the right. This isn’t flashy stuff, just a well-worked play that found a weakness in Washington’s defensive setup.

Outside of the near miss in the first half, Portland also defended well, and Washington struggled to find many chances. Overall, this was the most decisive performance yet over the full 90 minutes by this junior Thorns team.

Categories
Soccer Timbers

Takeaways from Portland and San Jose’s 1-1 Draw at Providence Park

To view this content, you must be a member of the Rose City Review Patreon
Already a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to access this content.