To view this content, you must be a member of the Rose City Review Patreon
Already a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to access this content.
The Chicago Red Stars and the Portland Thorns could be two sides of the same coin. Both have young, brilliant, marquee forwards (Mal Swanson for Chicago and Sophia Smith for Portland), brilliant keepers (Alyssa Naeher and Bella Bixby, respectively), a long history making the NWSL playoffs, and both teams are currently for sale after a myriad of scandals and abuse were perpetrated and ignored by the teams’ front offices.
However, the Thorns have been able to maintain their status-quo performances on the field while the Red Stars have floundered greatly so far in the 2023 season. Granted, Swanson is out with an unfortunate knee injury, and Chicago lost most of their midfield during the league’s first free agency period while the Thorns have largely retained their roster. But the talent, particularly in Chicago’s back line, is far better than scorelines have reflected.
The Thorns, back at home after a two-game road stretch, desperately needed to bounce back to the dominance with which they started the season. After two consecutive 3-3 ties and a 2-1 loss to Houston, it was clear that the Thorns needed a mental reset. Their tactics and ability to score goals were clearly still on display throughout all three games, but the defensive mindset and ability to shake off mistakes and close out games effectively was noticeably absent.
While the resounding 4-0 win over Chicago at home—which marked the third time that the Thorns have scored three times in the first 16 minutes of a game—might not have been the team’s best performance of the season, it provided the mental reset that Portland so desperately needed and reminded them of the importance of playing with joy.
There is no one player who embodies this mantra better than Meghan Klingenberg, who is emphatic with her words and isn’t afraid to speak blatantly on her feelings with the team. Her pregame hype huddles are iconic, and the passion she has for the Thorns is palpable, so it is only right to look at the Thorns’ stomping of Chicago through her own words.
Kling began her overall thoughts by saying that, “It’s the first time in a couple games where I felt like we put together really good stretches of quality minutes, limited their opportunities and looked more like us. We looked like we are having fucking fun. When we look like that, we are at our best. I think we are pretty unstoppable when we are at our best.”
The Thorns had four different goal scorers against Chicago: Kelli Hubly, Crystal Dunn, Olivia Moultrie, and Natalia Kuikka. Half of those players are defenders for the club, while Dunn plays defense for the USWNT. If there’s one way for a shaky defense to have their confidence skyrocket, it would definitely be for them to outscore the entire forward line. The unexpected joy that Hubly exuded after she perfectly placed her volley into the far corner of the net set the ball in motion for how the rest of the game was going to go. The Thorns looked like they were having fun again.
Kling also referenced that it was the first time that the Thorns were “putting together really good stretches of quality minutes.” The Thorns put up absurd numbers. They had 12 shots on target out of 22 total, and limited Chicago to eight shots total, none on target. The Thorns had 124 passes in the final third and 43 touches in Chicago’s box—showcasing their relentlessness in their high press and creating numerous opportunities. Compare these numbers to the previous game against Houston, where the Thorns had 74 passes in the final third and only 12 entrances into their opponent’s box, and it’s clear that the Thorns had a more successful press.
When a team has been imbued with as much off field trauma as the Thorns have, it can become hard to focus on the on field successes. That is what I think is happening with the Chicago Red Stars. Throughout the ongoing sale of their club, they have lost investment and belief in the players, which in turn makes it harder for them to perform on field. The Thorns, on the other hand, have had consistent support from general manager Karina LeBlanc and the die-hard Riveters that has allowed them to keep up their desired level of performance on the field.
Kling, who is not a captain nominally but embodies the leadership and passion of one, is right when she says that the fun the team is having is directly correlated to their successes on the field. I hope that the Thorns are able to take this regained confidence after a rocky stretch and show San Diego who the best team on the west coast really is.
Last Saturday, the Portland Thorns earned their second consecutive 3-3 draw, fighting back from going down a goal three separate times against the North Carolina Courage.
“I think to find ourselves down three times, it’s probably hard for to wrap me head around,” Thorns head coach Mike Norris said after the game, “but group kept pushing”—showing a resilience and rebound that Norris said he was “really proud of.”
So, let’s break all that down.
Portland was unlucky to go down in the first minute, after a North Carolina cross deflected weirdly off of Thorns defender Emily Menges. It’s the third time the Thorns have conceded off an unfortunate deflection this year—the first being a Meaghan Nally own-goal against the San Diego Wave—and I’m not really sure what to make of that happening twice in the first month and a half of 2023 play. Are the new white kits cursed? Possibly.
North Carolina’s other two goals came in the forms of a brilliant individual effort from Kerolin and Courage rookie Olivia Wingate nutmegging Menges and getting off a cross to meet Victoria Pickett’s near-post run.
“I don’t want to be a team that’s conceded three goals,” Norris said, “but I didn’t think it was a poor defensive performance. I thought it was anything but that, to be honest.”
I don’t think Norris is outright wrong—it wasn’t an awful defensive performance—but the Thorns definitely could’ve been better on North Carolina’s third goal.
In that play, the Courage are working the ball up Portland’s left flank. As we’ve alluded to above, Kerolin sends a ball ahead to Wingate, who drives endline and ‘megs Menges. Klingenberg has been drawn out to mark Kerolin, so it’s center-back Kelli Hubly who has to step to Wingate, leaving Pickett in space.
As we see above, Hubly stepping leaves Natalia Kuikka marking two Courage players (Pickett near post and Tyler Lussi far post). Dunn and Sam Coffey have been standing at the top of the box and are just beginning their runs to cover—but it’s too late.
Of the goals, this one feels the most like a situation that could’ve been avoided with a little more communication and anticipation. Even if Menges doesn’t get beat here, the Thorns are defending three-on-three, which is a situation they’d want to avoid.
(In Menges’ defense, she also wasn’t the only Thorn to get beat on a North Carolina goal; Coffey dove in too early against Kerolin on the Courage’s second goal, getting beat and leaving Kerolin with far too much space in the center of the field.)
Still, I don’t think that’s a cause for concern, yet. Even though individual players got beat on North Carolina’s second and third goals, Portland’s other defenders weren’t able to effectively drop back and cover—an issue that will hopefully resolve itself as the team gets more used to playing together. Or as Crystal Dunn put it postgame, “We’re still early enough in the season where we know that it’s just these growing pains that we’re going to go through.”
Outside of capitalizing on their chances, North Carolina, for their part, put together a pretty solid performance against the Thorns—especially in their work limiting Portland’s space in midfield. The Thorns, for their part, were forced to play wide or find quick passes through the center of the park, the latter of which they struggled to do consistently.
“We’re a team that’s at our best when we’re fluid,” Dunn said, “when we’re able to break teams down and not be stagnant.” Portland’s second goal was a prime example of that, she said.
In the buildup to the goal, we can see the Courage’s pressure—and the Thorns successfully playing out of that through quick passes. After Sophia Smith’s flick on to Meghan Klingenberg’s overlapping run, Dunn just has to push toward goal from where she’s sitting at the top of North Carolina’s box to get on the end of the cross.
Portland’s other two goals—the first from Dunn and the third from Olivia Moultrie—show another area where the Thorns found success: in their late runs out of midfield.
While we’re here, let’s take a moment to appreciate Moultrie’s game-tying goal—the cherry on top of her impressive performance off the bench.
Hey Liv, you dropped this during that unreal goal 👑#BAONPDX pic.twitter.com/fmdicfpNNG
— Portland Thorns FC (@ThornsFC) May 7, 2023
It’s still incredibly silly that, as a 17-year-old, she isn’t eligible for a player of the week nomination after that.
The Portland Thorns claimed sole possession of the top of the NWSL table with their 2-0 win over Racing Louisville on Saturday evening. All time against Louisville the Thorns are 5-0-0, scoring 12 goals and conceding just one. While the scoreline may suggest a dominant performance over Louisville, the game itself left fans nervous that the Thorns would concede a goal late—not closing out the game with the professionalism and deftness the team normally shows.
The largest reason the Thorns nearly threatened their dominant 2-0 first half lead was due to the sheer number of minutes that this roster has played recently. Portland was coming off of a stretch of three games in eight days that fell right on the end of an international break. Natalia Kuikka, Christine Sinclair, Adriana Leon, Hina Sugita, and Rocky Rodríguez played international matches in Europe, while Crystal Dunn, Becky Sauerbrunn, and Sophia Smith played in the United States.
Here are the minutes that each player played for their country during the week of April 6:
Kuikka: 180’ vs Slovakia
Sugita: 77’ vs. Portugal, 3’ vs Denmark
Rodríguez: 90’ vs Poland, 90’ vs Scotland
Sinclair: 63’ vs France
Leon: 76’ vs France
Dunn: 67’ vs Ireland
Smith: 135’ vs Ireland
Sauerbrunn: 120’ vs Ireland
Six of these eight players already seemed to be heavily favored in head coach Mike Norris’ preferred starting lineup (Leon, the new arrival, and Rodríguez, who consistently comes in around the 60’ mark in the midfield notwithstanding).
Norris’ starting XI against Houston on April 14 featured nine of 11 players that started against Louisville on April 22. This would not be much of a concern, if five of the players did not also start against San Diego midweek.
Here are the minutes that the starting XI against Lousiville played during the three game stretch:
Bella Bixby: 180’
Meaghan Klingenberg: 180’
Becky Sauerbrunn: 148’
Kelli Hubly: 270’
Reyna Reyes: 158’
Sam Coffey: 180’
Crystal Dunn: 137’
Morgan Weaver: 202’
Christine Sinclair: 158’
Hina Sugita: 174’
Sophia Smith: 197’
Compounded with the minutes that these core players played during the international break, many were averaging over 300 minutes in a two-week time span.
I bring all this up because the Thorns lost the game against Louisville in a clinical sense. Racing did not play a midweek game, and many of their players did not get minutes internationally during the break either. The miles on players legs showed from the initial whistle, and it was both mental and physical fatigue that prevented the Thorns from closing out the game in a clinical sense. Every touch seemed a little heavy, and their passes seemed inches off or hit too hard, allowing Racing’s players to read and intercept them. Despite outshooting Racing 20-12, the Thorns did not outplay Louisville by any means.
While, like Norris commented on postgame, the Thorns “did not have a complete performance [and] were just a bit off in moments,” they still were able to persevere and that is a testament to the professionalism of the individual players.
However, across the highest levels of professional women’s soccer, it seems as though long term ACL, hamstring, and calf injuries are plaguing players. The schedule of women’s players have increased to match men’s sides with the introduction of things like midweek Challenge Cup games, but funding and research toward preventative care and the anatomical differences between different genders has not kept pace. The Thorns have already lost one player to a season-ending ACL injury and have yet to name a new head trainer after the firing of Pierre Soubrier. All the positive culture and fun that the Thorns have at trainings and games cannot combat the “big ask coming back from Wednesday, travel Thursday, manage players [Friday] and then put a performance in [Saturday] to get the three points,” in the words of Norris.
While the players, except Sauerbrunn, who went off around the 60th minute with an ankle injury that was being monitored all week, seemed to have made it through the three game stretch unscathed, a game against Louisville, a team the Thorns have a comprehensive history of victory against, would have been a good chance to give some of the players who typically come off the bench an opportunity to get regular season minutes.
The Portland Thorns’ 2023 Challenge Cup campaign began in a manner opposite how they started the NWSL regular season; rather than recording a four-goal victory, Portland came away from Wednesday’s match with a 1-0 defeat to the San Diego Wave.
It wasn’t a bad game by any means. With both teams putting out rotated lineups on short turnaround, the Thorns managed to hold San Diego to seven shots—only one of which was on target. The Wave’s lone goal wasn’t the result of San Diego putting together something brilliant or Portland doing anything wrong on the defensive end; it was the result of an incredibly unlucky deflection that ended in a Meaghan Nally own-goal.
“I feel a bit unfortunate, just in terms of the bounces,” Thorns head coach Mike Norris said postgame, “but we move on.”
In lieu of an analysis of what worked and what didn’t from a team perspective—something that feels less meaningful given all the lineup changes and matches on short turnaround—I’m taking a look at three players who taught us something in their performances against San Diego.
Short-term loanee Adriana Leon made her Thorns debut less than a week after her first training session with the team.
“I still can’t really believe that I’m back here in the league and playing with Portland,” she said after the match.
Leon looked solid in her first 68 minutes as a Thorn. She showcased a willingness to get into tackles and push forward to put the Wave under pressure. Her two shots on the night—both of which forced San Diego goalkeeper Kailen Sheridan into diving saves—epitomized that pressure: In each instance, Leon intercepted a pass by the Wave defense, dribbled forward to set herself up, and got a shot off.
Her performance in the second half, especially, is what we can expect from Leon with the team, said Norris. “She’s a front-footed winger who likes to get in one-v-one duels from an attacking perspective and produce crosses,” he said. “And if she gets an eye for goal, she’ll take it.”
The key for Leon, as with any new player, will be developing chemistry with the rest of the Thorns’ attackers. “We haven’t had too much time to train together,” she said. “But I’m excited to see what we can pull off moving forward.”
Leon’s already shown her ability to pick out attacking opportunities; if she can do that in-step with Sophia Smith, Portland will have added another lethal wrinkle to their already talent-heavy attack.
Last weekend was a bit of a rough go for Reyna Reyes, who made her first professional start in Portland’s 1-1 draw against the Houston Dash.
After that game, Norris said he had no doubt Reyes would bounce back stronger—especially now that she had gotten her first-start nerves out of the way. That Norris was willing to give her the nod for a second game is a testament to his belief in her, a belief that seems well-founded given her performance against the Wave.
“I think she grew from her performance against Houston,” he said. “I think you can see her versatility being able to play on the left and right side, getting stuck into tackles, likes to play forward. I think she’s still coming to grips with the speed of the league, but happy with the start.”
Norris’ assessment feels accurate of what Reyes showed against San Diego. She looked more confident stepping to balls and using her body to shut down Rachel Hill, was willing to take players on on the dribble, and was able to connect with her teammates more often than not. (She recorded a 63% pass accuracy.) If Reyes continues to grow at the rate she has over these first couple games, she’ll cement herself as an invaluable piece of this team sooner rather than later.
Sitting behind Bella Bixby in the goalkeeper depth chart, Hogan hasn’t had all that many chances to show what she can do. Still, she had an opportunity Wednesday night, and she made the most of it.
“I think the first thing that stood out was just her presence and her demeanor,” Norris said, “really calm and confident. Really composed, looked like she had a lot of games under her belt… I think it was solid confidence and a composed performance of somebody probably beyond her experience and her years.”
Even with the unlucky deflection-turned-own-goal, Hogan looked solid throughout the night. Her stellar positioning and solid handling made the couple times she came to claim a ball off a corner or cross look easy. And she was ready to deny San Diego’s Sofia Jakobsson an early chance.
SHELBY HOGAN APPRECIATION POST 🧤 #BAONPDX pic.twitter.com/Rmlf94mMxa
— Portland Thorns FC (@ThornsFC) April 20, 2023
It’s safe to say the Nadine Angerer goalkeeper development academy is alive and well.
Emily Menges made her first appearance for the Thorns since Aug. 24, 2022, when she came on as a second-half sub for Reyes. Especially given the last six months, it’s nice to see her back on the pitch and looking like she hasn’t missed a beat.